Hello - Karma has been working with Community, dGov, and dTech on building an MVP reputation system for Aragon contributors. They aggregate contributor activity across Discord, Discourse, Aragon Voice, on-chain voting and quantify those activities to generate Karma (reputation) score. You can see the Aragon dashboard here Aragon DAO Contributors Leaderboard.
If you are a contributor interested in seeing your forum activity along with other stats, please link your wallet to your forum handle. You can go to the dashboard and click the “Link” and follow the steps. You can see a loom video of the entire process here
Verifying my forum identity for aragon governance addr: 0x8c6d70c7e73eAD837e09EEF0a321824544C07BFE sig: 0x8305d9c8cf5486a8e8dcda28683fb7effc54ecce8da97613dc46a3c4ba39f9ac23a988b510b24a085dc625b07f6de69acacb9ae3fcfad6c948bcb62902bf6e621b #aragongovernance
Verifying my forum identity for aragon governance addr: 0xF67825D3bdE95a0Bbb1a063e06D51b79e7061C05 sig: 0x6bb24b2ad31b02f34ad81cb047cec5a4a6371f37877bec2aeb50ba573e5805d72b5ced00720cacc8f58e8e3d2997cd580f32dfa2669e561e623b0218a18cd1061c #aragongovernance
Hello friend, this is very interesting! Can you explain if this is an ANDAO initiative? If so how does it work if the DAO charter will be terminated and funds moved (I see this discussion and vote is up but of course not decided yet). Apologies for my english as it’s not my native language! Thank you! Edit: I think my question is: what is the goal! thank you!
Verifying my forum identity for aragon governance addr: 0x3E31155a1c17c9F85e74828447aec412090a4622 sig: 0xbe09c08a692787bd18b5e1b655795b0126b1ccf761c857506acba3743d0142ed4e9ff393278c8cee8492d8eba4124d0c6f897d882b9ffe29ac9d9d2cc93708461c #aragongovernance
Right now dTech is testing this out with Karma. We have arbitrarily set parameters in the algo with Karma to obtain a score. This will change later if Aragon decides to move forward with this. Additionally, it is not only Discorse… it is Discord, Voice and on chain data. Potentially in the future there will be Dework, github, and Notion stats.
What will Aragon do with this data? That is up to me, you and everyone else at Aragon. That discussion will come later but it could be:
Just extra data token holders can view before delegating their tokens
enforcing a certain Karma score before you can be a paid delegate, core contributor, or contributor
I will be doing an AMA next week on this. Date and time to be determined.
Verifying my forum identity for aragon governance addr: 0x9aB3971e1b065701C72C5f3cAFbF33118dC51ae9 sig: 0xb78f43d621b1f44edb24c5db61cd9ab28ae2dad2f344f3f4dc8de0a1eaf8eb0c4a8749c910680c6b44fb94e09ed725cc1269b256eca41544dcce3a250f2031191c #aragongovernance
Verifying my forum identity for aragon governance addr: 0x96FBd75834FD9498f8b1E485D29541e74b8E6Ac7 sig: 0x07aa570e205b99f7bc120c238a9c780cb502a479ddfddc8a6544fda88d6df3e552f912c86930f39a8e5c3fdf9bd2437890cccb73d131f31e3713f4e764a5b51a1b #aragongovernance
Verifying my forum identity for aragon governance addr: 0xacc1E844db1569bbCb5d5a46A64cF5288C511796 sig: 0x75424006549bbee5fa879302af4b064beab7c6448d7569c6541bde018366004a3da04565df4aa40bc56c5c555ae7ae5e899140a5150a3b549702102caaf1a7081c #aragongovernance
Verifying my forum identity for aragon governance addr: 0x1E8eE48D0621289297693fC98914DA2EfDcE1477 sig: 0xf91df22592438116868bfe35c7a0b45482de24cdae9ed53fc5d99aa9ba52a5da3fc23c62ca086d5265233922c16595d15b9e2544b1f9a5f63c648ca15f3429711c #aragongovernance
Verifying my forum identity for aragon governance addr: 0x802FAEf2D36173Ff3a0E50dCfc0403BefeFd3eD7 sig: 0x59d8709488321669e9353b5543bb5862394415fdcd19597a08bf7e5aec9fec445fff7c923c69ab208411a5fdd949b6a1fcf6845bff3f97965b94c503de268be21b #aragongovernance
Verifying my forum identity for aragon governance addr: 0xbF0f24fD34bC76CD6d8Eb37cc99d4477ed3a98FB sig: 0xe1aa0f8a697ce700ae9dec3a78d309b380fed68347a2e0eb9e63c5ec521e137e5d68718290d64535d4c4b401489762e8a5315002ec714c5aaecb0959d0c532d81c #aragongovernance
Thank you for this initiative! It’s a cool dashboard, indeed.
One piece of feedback on phrasing - calling those of us who have connected a wallet “delegates” can be misleading because, as part of Aragon’s transition to a DAO, there will be delegates in the more direct sense of the word, with delegated voting power.
Something like “contributors” or “governance participants” is more representative.
Disclaimer: I am not a native speaker. It might be clear to others that the listed wallets are not actually delegates
Verifying my forum identity for aragon governance addr: 0xe48394953fbf37e978121dDF74F28Fd1d2af41A3 sig: 0x4f44f864a92d2e0e70b8704acd8e1c083995de5e2e8def276e2fc92450d45d51075ca2c34c05f929707e7ff40157b8d662834f450e2ac47c0ea19287a3f109cf01 #aragongovernance
Agreed, just because you connect a wallet does not mean you are a delegate. I think you are referring to the letterboard where it says “Top Delegates”.
Even with “contributors” or “governance participants” it would depend on how the weighting is done. Something I am trying to drive discussion about and will hold more community decision making sessions for this. But this discussion should not be here in Meta. I will get it changed in the short term and make a note of this for future discussion, and soon there will be a central place for all these discussions.
thank you!